How Stories Are Killed


Tonight, I have been watching a remarkable story unfold on Twitter. Here's the end of it in a retweet from Clay Shirky: 


We did it!  crosses $40K in funding, will keep covering murders in DC. Thanks and congrats to everyone who pitched in!

This is a deduction from afar, but the beginning of the story must have been a decision by the conventional media in Washington, DC, to stop covering every homicide in their community. Maybe there were just too many murders and there was an opportunity cost to covering them. Maybe there was research suggesting that readers stopped reading and viewers stopped viewing when they were asked to consume the facts and images of murder scenes. Maybe the chamber of commerce logic won the day, and editors were convinced of the argument that bad news was bad business. Maybe the advertisers couldn't sell as much happiness when the reality outside the door was so different and so sad. 

Maybe murders in DC just became commonplace. And boring. I am here under the influence of the arguments of Pratt and Labov, but when the breach is no longer seen as a breach, when the breach is not seen as a departure from the norm, then it's no longer tellable and shareable. End of story. 

When a murder is still terrifying, dangerous, weird or wild or heart-breaking, when it is still a breach of the norm, then it makes some sense to report it. 

Whatever the reason was, the reporting stopped. And that compelled those behind homicidewatch.org to answer back. 

This is what the site says about its mission: 
The site relaunched in August 2011, adding a custom database to track homicide cases from crime to conviction, building the area's most complete public resource to for the people who need it most: victim's families, suspects' families, and all others affected by violent crime in D.C. 
What a refreshingly unabashed defence of the storyteller's reaction to the irreversible fact of crime. Sad that it has to be made, but honest and clear-eyed, nonetheless.

Edmonton Journal photo from four days ago
From the time last century when I was a crime reporter at The Edmonton Sun to the days I was the news director at CTV Edmonton, I heard and felt each of the pressures listed above when it came to reporting murders.  I'm not in that part of the media world anymore, but I think it's accurate to say that those arguments, even in Edmonton, continue to have force. Besides, crime reporting takes time and resources and a reporter's touch to build contacts, and all of that is expensive. Those documents you want? You actually have to go and chase them down yourself. 

But, not covering murders from start to finish doesn't make your community a safer place. It just puts a gate up in the community. Unavoidably, it draws a conclusion about the type of community you live in, and about the kinds of lives that matter. 

Anyways, congrats to those who run and support homicidewatch.org. They strike me as the kind of people who would be very happy for the day they have no work to do. 



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

:)

Image
One of the joys and dangers of studying in the MACT program is that you start to feel scared enough to feel confident enough to fool around and try simple new things with technology. The danger is that you're not good enough not to spend most of your time fiddling around doing those things. And, so, this morning I am proud to announce that, taken by the hand, I have managed to embed html vimeo code into my blog. Please, no applause. This is not much, I know. Your basic 8 year old can do more. Asleep. But it is a minor accomplishment for me, because of me. And how I get in the way with my pre-wired reaction that new things won't work. The effect of that kind of thinking (or that lack of thinking) is that I transform the machine in front of me into an antagonistic force working to undo me. But it does remind me of me when I attribute malevolence to the skies when they conspire to bring rain on a morning of golf! Either way, that's bad storytelling. On another leve...
Read more

Hello!

Image
The potential socialness of a bicycle is built right into its roofless and windshieldless and doorless frame. It is easy to say hello on a bicycle. Like this morning. These sidewalkers nodded to me in unison at the exact instant I nodded to them. I said hello to the jogger, and he waved back. Hi, I said, to the dog walkers and the dog, and they nodded a greeting back. Both joggers smiled and said hello as our lives passed. I said hello to the squirrel. I said hello to the woman walking with poles and she returned the hello. The jogger looked over and I said hello as she said hello. I said hello to this fellow egg picker upper and we talked for a couple of minutes. Her bicycle comes out April 1. She is excited. Hello, I said. Hi, she said. I said hello to the  man on the other end of this leash and he said he and his dog were enjoying the beautiful morning. I said hello to this woman and she said hello, and we laughe...
Read more

Some Late Thoughts Listening To Wheat Kings

Image
Wheat Kings in Edmonton, July , 2016 I asked a friend at work what The Tragically Hip song Wheat Kings was about, and he paused for a beat longer than he would have had he not considered the same question many times. And then said: "I don't know." I took this as a good sign both of his humility and the song's profundity. It was an honest question. I don't know much about The Hip. They were cool for the first time when I was watching my wife raise our children, and trying to help the mission where I could. Those were busy days. The 1990s are my mediated decade, preserved by photographs of my younger self. Among the art that didn't get in was The Tragically Hip's. And it was a dishonest question. I knew the song was about David Milgaard's wrongful conviction and wrongful jail time served for the murder of Saskatoon nurse Gail Miller. And it was an honest question, because song's visual shards—that weathervane, a killer's face lit ...
Read more